Jeff Neese’s essay on vocational horticulture makes a straightforward workforce argument: the greenhouse industry’s shortage of experienced growers begins earlier than most recruiting conversations. Neese, a biological solutions advisor at BioWorks with more than 35 years in commercial horticulture and IPM, draws on his own path through a high-school horticulture program at Warren Central High School in Indianapolis. There, teachers Phil Pitts and Pam Greene gave him something he says too few young people now receive: a chance to experience horticulture before being asked to choose a career.
A doorway before a career decision
Neese describes walking into the school greenhouse during an Indiana winter. Outside, the landscape was cold, gray and dormant. Inside, the greenhouse was warm, humid, green and alive. He did not realize it then, but that doorway would shape the rest of his life. Pitts brought real-world experience as a grower and landscape designer and set high expectations for what students should know. Greene taught floriculture as part of the vocational program, exposing students more directly to the part of the industry that became central to Neese’s professional life.
The program was not built around memorizing plant names, completing worksheets or growing a few plants for a spring fundraiser. Students were expected to understand plants and, most importantly, learn to grow them well. The work followed biological schedules: plants need water on weekends; insects and diseases do not wait for Monday morning; crops respond to light, temperature, water and nutrition whether school is in session or not. For Neese, the result was not simply exposure to a subject. It was a career direction.
He chose not to go to college and entered horticulture after high school. More than 40 years later, he remains in the field. He is careful to say the industry still needs university-trained horticulturists, plant scientists, breeders, researchers and growers. His point is that a four-year degree should not be treated as the only successful route, nor should college be the first place a young person discovers horticulture.
The pipeline starts too late
Industry discussions about workforce development often focus on the difficulty of finding growers, especially growers with practical production experience. Neese notes that the conversation also covers succession planning, recruiting college graduates, developing assistant growers and competing for a limited pool of horticultural talent. In his view, that conversation may begin too late. Before asking where the next generation of growers will come from, the industry should ask where young people are supposed to discover horticulture in the first place. A 15- or 16-year-old is not necessarily going to wake up one morning and decide that greenhouse production sounds like a fascinating career. Someone has to show them.
That is why Neese sees high-school vocational horticulture as important to the industry’s future. But a greenhouse behind a school is not enough. A greenhouse is a living laboratory, and operating one requires knowledge, commitment and time. Agriculture teachers may be responsible for broad subject areas, and expecting every one of them to also be an accomplished greenhouse grower, crop scheduler, irrigation specialist, diagnostician, IPM practitioner and environmental-control expert is not realistic. Nor should teachers be expected to develop all those skills alone. This is where Neese believes the industry needs to step in.
School greenhouses need technical partners
Neese proposes that commercial greenhouse operations treat their local school greenhouses as partners. The goal would not be to take the greenhouse away from the teacher or dictate the curriculum. It would be to become a technical resource for the teacher and students. Growers could help develop an achievable crop plan and set realistic standards for irrigation, fertility, pH, EC, temperature and crop timing. They could walk the greenhouse with students and teach them how to scout rather than simply telling them what is wrong with a plant. They could show how sticky cards are used, how roots are examined, how nutritional problems are diagnosed and how growers think through problems and make decisions. They could also help teachers understand equipment that may already be in the greenhouse but is not being used to its potential.
That relationship would give teachers something valuable: someone knowledgeable to call when something goes wrong. Neese argues that the industry possesses an extraordinary amount of practical growing knowledge, yet most of it stays inside commercial greenhouse walls. If the industry is serious about developing its future workforce, some of that knowledge needs to find its way into the classroom. Not every vocational horticulture instructor needs to already be another Phil Pitts or Pam Greene. Teachers need to be surrounded with enough industry expertise, encouragement and support that their students can experience horticulture at a meaningful level.
Internships are a snapshot, not the whole movie
Summer internships are important, but Neese does not believe they are enough by themselves. For most high-school students, summer is the only extended period when they can work full time. That can provide a narrow view of greenhouse production. Depending on the operation, much of the diversity and activity of spring may already be gone. It is hot and humid, and because the students are inexperienced seasonal employees, they can easily end up doing whatever job nobody else particularly wants to do that day. They might be sticking poinsettias, spacing crops, moving plants or cleaning houses.
Neese says there is nothing wrong with those jobs. They are part of commercial horticulture, and every good grower needs to understand the physical work involved in producing a crop. But if that is all a teenager experiences, the industry should not be surprised if greenhouse horticulture does not look particularly exciting as a career. The student has experienced greenhouse labor, but not necessarily greenhouse management.
To understand growing, students need to experience how greenhouse production changes throughout the year. They need fall crops and shortening days, winter’s lower light and humidity challenges, spring propagation and the controlled chaos of peak production, and summer’s heat, irrigation demands and preparation for the next production cycle. There are different crops, different problems and different decisions at every stage. An eight-week summer internship gives a student one snapshot. Learning horticulture requires seeing the whole movie.
From summer job to career path
Neese argues that the school greenhouse and the commercial greenhouse should function as extensions of one another. If a participating grower understands what students are learning in the classroom, the summer internship becomes the next chapter of their education rather than an unrelated summer job. If students have learned about pH and EC during the school year, they can see how a commercial operation monitors them. If they have been learning scouting and IPM, they can join a crop walk. If they have studied irrigation and fertility, they can see injectors, water systems and fertilizer programs.
Even repetitive production work becomes more meaningful when students understand the decisions behind it. Instead of only teaching a student how to stick a poinsettia cutting, a grower can explain where that cutting fits into the production schedule, what happens during rooting, when the crop will be transplanted, what to watch for along the way and why hitting the finished-crop date matters. The work is not eliminated. It is turned into learning.
That partnership could continue throughout the school year: commercial growers visiting classrooms, assisting teachers with crop planning, helping students troubleshoot their greenhouse and inviting classes into commercial operations at different points in the production cycle. By the time students arrive for summer employment, they are no longer just inexperienced seasonal labor. They are beginning to understand the why behind the work they are asked to do.
Neese also sees a recruiting opportunity in that relationship. A student may first meet a company as a sophomore taking horticulture classes. As a junior, the student might visit the greenhouse, work with one of the growers or spend the summer with the team. During the senior year, the student can continue developing abilities in the school greenhouse while maintaining that relationship with the operation. When graduation comes, that young person should not have to wonder whether horticulture can provide a real career. They should already be able to see the path in front of them.
Another respected route
Some of the most rewarding growers Neese has worked with are people he had the opportunity to help develop. They did not arrive knowing everything. They learned the crops and the operation from the ground up, gradually took on greater responsibility and gained confidence because somebody invested the time to teach them. That is more than recruiting. It is developing a horticulturist, and Neese suggests the industry should do more of it before young people leave high school.
College may be the right next step for many students, and Neese says it should be encouraged when it is. But for the student who cannot attend college, does not want to attend college or, like him, simply knows they want to get started, there should be another respected path into the profession. A talented 18-year-old with several years of vocational horticulture, meaningful commercial exposure and the mentorship of experienced growers should not be viewed simply as unskilled labor. That is a young horticulturist at the beginning of a career. Give them responsibility, continue teaching them and show them where that career can lead.
What the industry can do
Schools cannot be expected to solve the horticulture industry’s workforce challenges alone, and commercial growers cannot solve vocational education alone. Neese sees an enormous opportunity between those two worlds. The industry can continue attending career fairs, posting job openings and wondering why applicants do not arrive with the practical growing experience it is looking for. Or it can become involved earlier: find the agricultural education or horticulture program in the community, meet the teacher, walk through the school greenhouse, ask what is needed and offer knowledge, not just old equipment and leftover plants.
Neese urges growers to invite students into their operations in February as well as June. Let them scout, test EC, look at roots, see great crops and problem crops, make mistakes, ask questions, diagnose problems and understand the decisions behind producing a quality crop. When students come to work in summer, growers should not just give them the job nobody else wants. They should give them a reason to want that job someday.
Neese closes with a personal image: somewhere today another teenager is walking into a greenhouse for the first time and could become an exceptional grower, IPM specialist, propagator, production manager or greenhouse owner. Pitts and Greene opened that door for him. Horticulture was not a fallback if college did not work out; it was the opportunity. More than four decades later, part of what those teachers taught him still walks into every greenhouse with him.
The essay’s implication is less about one school or one company than about timing and partnership. If the next generation is already sitting in high-school classrooms, the industry can wait for them to appear as applicants or help grow them earlier. Neese favors the second approach: not taking over vocational education, but placing commercial knowledge, expectations and mentorship close enough to school greenhouses that students can see a career path before graduation.
